Inside Mount Roman Shades Vs. Outside Mount Roman Shades
Image by Another Human
Once you’ve chosen a fabric and fold style, one question remains before you order: should your roman shade sit inside or outside the window recess? It matters more than it seems, because it changes how the window looks, how much light the shade blocks and how you measure. In short, roman shades inside the window recess look neat and tailored, show off a handsome window frame and suit kitchens, bathrooms and shades layered under drapes, provided the recess is at least 2 in deep. Roman shades outside the window recess suit shallow or small windows, block more light at the edges, clear the glass completely when raised and leave room for another shade beneath.
The right answer for your home lies in deciphering which of these positions can meet your aesthetic mandate and functional requirements to the full. With a well-rounded exposition on the nuances and benefits of each mounting position, you can discern which one suits more for your settings. Let’s head into it -
Inside Mount or Outside Mount: Which is Best?
 
Â
Apart from the choice of fabric, accessories and fold style, custom roman shades offer one more level of customization - that of the mounting position. Where you mount the shade is of immense consequence to maximizing its functional capacities, and impacts other design decisions as well. Therefore, the decision on the mounting position has to be taken after keen consideration of what each option holds in store for you. Let’s have a quick review of each:Â
Inside Mount Roman Shades
Image by R/Terior Studio
In the inside mounting position, the roman shade is affixed to the ‘ceiling’ of the window recess so that it sits snugly inside the frame, covering the recess from end to end. When the shade is raised, it stacks with its neat folds on the top, dressing the window like a valance. The top portion of the window is occupied by the shade’s stack if it is mounted inside the window frame.Â
This position is especially ideal in some situations, as listed below:Â
ELABORATE TRIM: If your window has an ornate trim or crown molding that deserves to be flaunted, mounting the shade inside the window makes sure that the entire trim is exposed all the time. The shade does not overlap the trim, and the window trim acts as a frame for the shade, accentuating its visual appeal. So, inside mounting enables both elements - the roman shade as well as the trim - to shine.
MINIMALIST HOME: When you want the most minimalistic and sleek approach to stay in line with the contemporary feel of your home, inside mounting is ideal as the roman shade commands no space other than the window itself. If you blend the fabric color with that of the wall, it will sink into the architecture and go unnoticed in true minimalist fashion.
LAYERING WITH DRAPES: If you plan to ‘overtreat’ your shades with drapes, keeping the roman shades inside the frame allows both layers of window treatments their own space to operate so that they are not in friction.
BESPOKE APPEAL: Roman shades carry a custom look regardless of how they are mounted as they are perfect-fit treatments that are tailored to stringently fit the specific measurements of the window. However, when inside-mounted, the roman shade looks especially tailored and perceptibly bespoke because it sits snugly in the recess, evidently sewn to perfection for a specific window.
NURSERY & KIDS’ ROOMS: When you want the roman shade to be inaccessible to your little ones, mounting the shade inside the frame is more promising.
KITCHENS & BATHROOMS: In kitchens, laundry rooms and bathrooms, the inside mounting position helps to keep the roman shade less vulnerable to accidental splashes.
WINDOWS WITH FURNITURE UNDERNEATH: When there is inbuilt window seating/storage space underneath the window-sill, as is often the case with bay windows, or if there is a piece of furniture like a study desk directly in front of the window, mounting the shade inside ensures that it won’t skim on the countertop or be hindered during its operation.
SMALL ROOMS: In a small room, an inside-mounted shade is a space-saver as it does not take any additional wall space but accommodates itself in the window itself.
Outside Mount Roman Shades
Image by Anson Smart
In this position, the roman shade is mounted outside the window’s frame. It is either affixed to the wall above the window, or in some cases, to the ceiling of the room when the window is close to the ceiling.Â
Since the shade is placed outside the window, it is not limited by the size of the window as it happens in the case of inside mounting. There is scope to extend the shade beyond the window frame, if so desired.Â
When the shade is mounted outside, it is typically mounted a few inches above the window trim. This allows the shade to stack up on the wall above when it is folded up, not in front of the window. In this way, the window will be cleared fully when the shades are folded up. Hence, the shade will not take away any space from the window for its stacking room as opposed to if it were mounted inside, blocking the upper portion of the window.Â
In addition, since the shade is generously scaled - broader and longer than the window - it offers more coverage, and in turn, better light control, insulation and privacy.
This position is especially ideal in some situations, as listed below:Â
SHALLOW WINDOW RECESS: The White Window’s roman shade hardware needs at least 2 in of flat surface inside the recess to be installed securely. So, if your window recess is less than 2 in deep, the outside mounting position is ideal.
SMALL WINDOW: If your window is small, and you mount the shade inside, it will make the window even smaller, both visually and literally. Here, outside mounting is advantageous as you can free the window fully when the shade is folded up. For best results, the shade should be mounted about 8-12 in above the window trim so that, when it is minimized, it will stack on the wall above the window, rather than in front of the window as would be the case with inside mounting. So, the window’s meager capacity to bring in light and air will not be further compromised. In addition, if you extend the shade both horizontally and vertically, you can create an optical illusion of a larger window. So, an outside mounting shade enables you to make the most of a small window and masks its smallness when designed with the right proportions.
MINIMIZE LIGHT LEAKS: If your roman shade is a standalone treatment in a bedroom or nursery, stitching it with larger proportions and mounting it outside the window will help to reduce the light bleed at the edges of the shades.
INWARD-OPENING WINDOW PANES: If your window pane opens inward, mounting the shade inside the window will hinder the operation of the window. You will have to minimize the shade and then manually lift it away from the window when you want to open the pane. Whereas if you mount the shade outside and make room for it to stack on the wall above, you can open and close the window pane without any fuss.
WINDOW TRIM SITUATION: If your window trim is show-worthy and you want to flaunt it, inside mounting is ideal. But, if you’re not keen to show it for any reason, outside mounting the shade is better.
MULTI-LAYERING OF WINDOW SHADES: If you envision adding a honeycomb shade or any other shade beneath your roman shade, mounting the roman shade outside the window is ideal. Both layers can operate freely without interfering with each other when one is mounted inside and the other outside.
Inside Vs Outside Mounting Position: The Moment of Choice
Image by Meghan Eisenberg
Both - inside mounting and outside mounting - have attractive traits and offerings of their own. Neither is better than the other, but one may be slightly more beneficial to your decor than the other depending on certain factors. Our stylists recommend evaluating both choices based on certain parameters so that you can arrive at your decision quickly. Some of them are:
LEVEL OF LIGHT CONTROL: Both, for the inside-mounted and the outside-mounted shades, you can expect a mild glow of light at the seams on a sunny day, but with the outside mounting position, you stand a better chance of minimizing it by extending it sufficiently on all sides. Therefore, if you want a high level of light control, mounting the shade outside the window recess is the better option, provided that you also extend it generously on all sides.Â
If you plan to ‘overtreat’ your inside-mounted roman shades with blackout drapes, the light leaks will be well-contained by the drapes anyway so that you will have no difficulty darkening the bedroom for sleep time. In such cases, this particular factor may not play a substantial role in your choice of mounting position for your roman shades.
MULTI-LAYERED WINDOW TREATMENTS: If you plan to install multiple window treatments, it is better to decide upon the entire set-up before you decide on the mounting position of your roman shade. If you mount the roman shade outside and then decide to ‘overtreat’ it with drapes, the drapes will have to be projected outward enough to accommodate the hardware of the shade behind it. This will end up looking bulky while the interior portion of the window goes as a wasted opportunity. On the contrary, if you later want to mount another perfect-fit treatment underneath the roman shade- such as cellular shades for example - mounting your roman shade inside will have negated the prospects altogether.Â
The general rule is: If you plan to add drapes, mount your roman shade inside the window and if you plan to add other shades, mount your roman shades outside the window. But based on the depth of the window and other factors, consider the viability of the entire set-up and on a window-to-window and room-to-room basis. If you’re pairing your shades with drapes, our sister store, The White Window Curtains, has a guide to layering drapes and roman shades.
ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES: If you live in a period home where the window trims reveal the beautiful history of the building or an artful detail, inside-mounted shades do a splendid job of bringing them under the spotlight. Mounting the shades outside and covering those wonderful details would make a sad compromise. Similarly, if you live in a modern house that has typically contemporary-looking shallow windows with straight-lined trims, outside mounting the shades may provide more light control and sometimes be the only option if the windows are not deep enough.
SIZE OF WINDOW: If the window is too small, inside mounting can make it seem even smaller and cluttered, so outside mounting (with generous extensions and higher placement) is better. If the window is large, both positions can be considered.
SIZE OF ROOM: In a small room, maximizing the available space is often the key goal. Here, inside-mounted shades can be the game changers as they provide all the functionality expected of window treatments without taking an extra inch from the room.Â
Inside or Outside Recess Roman Shades: FAQs
Should roman shades go inside or outside the window recess?
Inside if the recess is at least 2 in deep and you want a neat, built-in look or plan to add drapes. Outside if the recess is shallow, the window is small, the window opens inward or you want the most light control.
Do roman shades look better inside the window recess?
Often, yes, especially in period homes with handsome frames, as the shade sits snugly in the window and the frame stays on show. On small or plain modern windows, an outside shade mounted higher and wider can look better.
How deep does a window recess need to be for a roman shade?
Our hardware needs at least 2 in of flat surface to fix to. If the recess is shallower, or a handle or window latch gets in the way, mount the shade outside the recess.
How high above the window should an outside roman shade go?
A few inches above the frame is usual. On a small window, going 8-12 in higher lets the folds stack on the wall instead of over the glass, so you get all the daylight.
How much wider than the window should an outside roman shade be?
Most people add 3-4 in on each side; it’s optional, but it frames the window and cuts the light that creeps in at the edges.
Do outside mount roman shades block more light?
Yes. Inside or out, a little light shows at the edges, but a shade that overlaps the window on every side covers those gaps. Add a blackout lining for a bedroom.
Can you fit a roman shade inside the recess of an inward-opening window?
It’s best not to, as the shade gets in the way every time you open the window. Mount it outside and high enough to stack above the frame.
In Closing
Image by Forbes Masters
Depending on the parameters discussed above, you can decide whether mounting the roman shade outside or inside the window recess will be most beneficial for you. As you can guess by now, the answer to this question will vary from room to room and sometimes from window to window within the same room. There is no right or wrong, better or worse way of mounting a roman shade- the choice entirely hinges on the convenience of operation and the overall aesthetic appeal you are aiming for.
Whether you choose to mount the roman shade inside or outside the window, the hardware required is the same and the shades will be delivered to your home in a ready-to-install condition, complete with the hardware. But, deciding on the mounting position before you venture to place the order is important because the measurement technique will vary based on the mounting position. For an inside mount, measure the width of the recess at the top, middle and bottom and give us the narrowest figure (we take 3/8 in off so the shade runs freely), then measure the drop at both sides and the middle and give us the longest. For an outside mount, measure the area you want to cover; most people add 3-4 in on each side. Our Roman Shade Measurement Guide walks you through both. So, consider both inside mounting and outside mounting positions for all the alluring points they offer and what they hold at stake before you decide which is right for you. We hope that this guide has made the job much easier for you to make your decision confidently and to shop your roman shades online at The White Window. Every roman shade is custom made in any of our 2,500+ fabrics, handcrafted by artisans in India and delivered with all its hardware, ready to mount. If you need help, email us at hi@thewhitewindowshades.com.
Â
WINDOW WISDOM: ROMAN SHADES INSTALLATION GUIDE | HOW TO LAYER ROMAN SHADES WITH DRAPES